Weekly Review: Sofie’s Steaks

I’ve driven past Sofie’s Steaks in Morton, PA, a number of times and have wanted try them for a while. The fact that they were closed down for a fairly long time delayed that. But I noticed recently that they’ve re-opened and decided to give them a shot as my weekly cheesesteak.

Sofie’s offers both regular and American cheese whiz, as well as Provolone and sliced American cheese on their steaks. I went with sliced American and fried onions. My other decision was whether to get a regular, which is 10″ or a foot-long large sandwich. I was told on the phone that the large is only a buck-and-a-half more and you get a lot more meat. That was all the temptation I needed.

While it was not a bad cheesesteak by any means, there were some issues that prevent me from recommending it without reservation, particularly given the steak shop competition in that area.

The first problem, which I noticed as soon as I grabbed the bag containing my sandwich, was that the roll is softer than I prefer. It had a nice chew, but I like a crust with body, and this one didn’t have any.

The meat could have used just a tad more seasoning. I added that at home, but if I was eating it out, that would have been a bigger issue.

There was more than enough meat in this sandwich, but the cheese could have been distributed more evenly. The fist half that I ate didn’t have enough. The second half, which I enjoyed more than the first, had plenty. That’s not an issue I run into often with steaks.

If Sofie’s were the only steak shop in my area, I’d probably go there at least occasionally, but as I mentioned, they have a lot of competition. And they are about to have more, as Delco Steaks, one of my favorites, is opening a new location about a mile north of Sofie’s any day now. I suspect that will alleviate any desire I may have to give Sofie’s another shot.

A large, foot-long cheesesteak from Sofie’s Steaks of Morton, PA
This half had a good amount of cheese. That was not the case with the other half.

Published by BZ Maestro

Thank you for stopping by. If you enjoyed this post or the blog generally, please consider clicking the "like" button and signing up as a follower.

3 thoughts on “Weekly Review: Sofie’s Steaks

  1. I wonder if they lost some personnel when they shut down and there are now some new people making the sandwiches. Maybe give them another try in a couple of weeks to see if they’ve improved?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: