My Top 10 U.S. Presidents

This is arguably my first post on a serious subject. I am working on another, but it’s a bigger project that will take some time. 

I understand that a few of the men on this list are not viewed as politically correct and did things that are considered heinous by today’s moral standards. But I have a strongly negative view of judging figures from past eras by today’s standards. These presidents all had a huge impact on the country and were responsible for great accomplishments while in office. I’m not going to get into the negative things that are associated with them. This is a list about what made these men and their presidencies great.

While choosing these ten presidents was not that difficult for me, as this is a topic I’ve given a great deal of consideration to over the years, ranking them was not an easy task; particularly with numbers 4-9. There were a few close calls and I may make some changes in the order if I were to do this list again a year from now.

James K. Polk

10. James K. Polk (1845-1849):  Polk greatly expanded the size of the nation by fighting and winning the Mexican-American War, annexing Texas and craftily reaching a deal with Britain to gain the Oregon Territory for the U.S.

9.  Dwight D. Eisenhower (1953-1961): Ike was a very effective Cold War leader without getting us into any major military confrontations in the process. Just the fact that he had been such an effective military leader was probably a significant deterrent with our adversaries. He also established the system of Interstate highways that made it so much easier for Americans to maneuver around the country. And he sent the 101st Airborne to Little Rock after the Supreme Court ruled in favor of school integration in Brown vs. Board of Education to ensure that the Court’s ruling was carried out.

Harry S. Truman

8.  Harry S. Truman (1945-1953):  Truman was thrust into one of the more difficult set of circumstances faced by an American president with very little preparation and managed to get us through that period with a great deal of success. In addition to seeing us through the end of World War II, he established that we were in a Cold War with the Soviet Union and began the policy of Containment that lasted through many administrations.  He also stood tall with the Berlin Airlift and prevented the Kim family from controlling the entire Korean Peninsula.

Ronald Reagan

7.  Ronald Reagan (1981-1989):  While Reagan didn’t single-handedly win the Cold War for the United States, he played a leading role in its successful and peaceful conclusion. He did more than any other president to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on the planet and lessen the tensions that kept the world on edge for decades. He was also a brilliant communicator whose leadership style was the best of any president during my lifetime, which goes back to the Lyndon Johnson administration. But first and foremost, he demonstrated the legitimacy of the principle of Peace Through Strength. A weaker or less staunch leader would not have accomplished what he did. And like Eisenhower, he did it all without getting us into any major military confrontations.

Thomas Jefferson

6.  Thomas Jefferson (1801-1809):  As was the case with Polk, Jefferson significantly increased the size of the United States with the Louisiana Purchase. He also arranged for Americans to be present in that territory, initially by sending Lewis and Clark to explore it.  The two of them were responsible for the U.S. becoming a continental power. He saw the need for a national military academy and established West Point.  He also stabilized the nation’s economy and fought and won the war against the Barbary Pirates.

Andrew Jackson

5.  Andrew Jackson (1829-1837):  This may be the most controversial pick in today’s social landscape, but Jackson had a huge impact on the nation’s political and social fabric.  By being the first candidate to appeal to the little man, rather than the coastal elites, he changed the nature of the country. He founded the Democratic party. And he established that states may not disregard federal law by resisting South Carolina’s nullification effort.

Theodore Roosevelt

4.  Theodore Roosevelt (1901-1909):  Teddy raised our foreign policy profile greatly, putting us on the global map as a world power and international force. He fought the influence of the robber-barons, breaking up the huge monopolies that dominated the country in many ways during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. He also established the National Parks system.

George Washington

3.  George Washington (1789-1797): First and foremost, the father of our country set the standard and pattern of what a president should be in so many ways. One of the most important ways he did that was by giving up power voluntarily after two terms. Another was by creating a cabinet of advisors. He established federal power by personally leading the effort to put down the Whiskey Rebellion.

Franklin D. Roosevelt

2.  Franklin D. Roosevelt (1933-1945):  FDR is known primarily for leading the nation through the Great Depression and most of the way through World War II. His optimistic leadership and mass communication style set him apart from all other twentieth century presidents, with the possible exception of Reagan, and kept millions of Americans looking up when there was little reason to do so. He also established the Social Security system.

Abraham Lincoln, while running for President I included this photo because he has such a look of supreme confidence and ability. He truly looks like a man who could handle any problem, no matter how great. And so he could.
Abraham Lincoln during his presidency

1.  Abraham Lincoln  (1861-1865):  For a man with Lincoln’s humble origins to make himself into a national leader of supreme confidence and ability was one of the great accomplishments in human history. His determination and wisdom had much to do with the country remaining one and slavery coming to an end. Had he lived to serve out his second term, perhaps we would have avoided some of the greatest problems – including Reconstruction and Jim Crow – that plagued the nation over the next century.

Published by BZ Maestro

I live outside of Philadelphia and have been food-obsessed for as long as I can remember. After toying with the idea of starting a blog for a fairly long time, the extinction of a food-themed message board that I frequented for years prompted me to finally take action. Thank you for taking the time to check out what I've been up to - and eating. If you've enjoyed what you have read and seen, please consider clicking the "like" button and signing up as a follower.

8 thoughts on “My Top 10 U.S. Presidents

    1. “Juicy” refers to Barry’s post, not necessarily the Presidents, although if you give me a minute I could probably think of some way it applies to some of the Presidents. FDR always gets me frothing at the mouth. Would that qualify?


  1. It’s a very good list. Kudos for recognizing Polk. I would add LBJ to the list, Vietnam notwithstanding, based on his unrivaled leadership civil rights and his extraordinary list of legislative accomplishments. And you think some of your choices are unpopular!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. LBJ definitely had the accomplishments and impact to make it. He also had some bad negatives in my view. It was a tough balancing act.

      He was president when I was born, so I don’t remember him. Of the subsequent Democratic presidents, including the current one, Clinton is my favorite. After I posted with the line on Reagan’s great communication skills, it occurred to me that Clinton also excelled in that respect. I can recall him doing a great job at explaining his major policies or the decision to go into the Balkans beautifully and in an easy-to-understand manner to the nation. He just didn’t have the major accomplishments or long-term impact to make the list. He was president in between the Cold War and 9/11 and its aftermath, so there were fewer opportunities for him to make a major mark on the country.

      Obama was obviously a very skilled speech-maker. But I often felt his tone when addressing the country on major issues was like that of a teacher giving a lecture to his students. Reagan and Clinton came off much more positively in my view. They spoke to you as equals; not your superior.

      Nixon’s behavior/character obviously got in his way. I consider him to be one of the greatest foreign policy presidents though.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: